Former Israel Security Agency director Ami Ayalon issued a strong critique of the Shin Bet's recent behavior, warning that the exclusion of Arab citizens from political participation poses a significant danger to the nation's democratic foundations and security. Speaking at the Palmach Museum in Tel Aviv on Thursday, Ayalon addressed an audience gathered for the launch of Dr. Amir Gilat's book, Dam Adam Adama, which focuses on the Wadi Ara region.

During his address, Ayalon contended that Israel is failing to honor its commitment to equality for Arab citizens. He drew parallels to the findings of the Shamgar Commission, which investigated the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin and the handling of informant Avishai Raviv, known by the codename Champagne. Ayalon emphasized that the commission's warnings against stigmatizing legitimate communities through political means remain highly relevant in the current context.

The former Navy commander stated that when the Shin Bet acts in ways that harm democracy by preventing a legitimate population from participating, it deals a devastating blow to the very institutions it is tasked with protecting. He expressed hope that these words would be heard by agency employees, senior officials, and all citizens of the state. Ayalon extended his criticism to the government, accusing it of adopting an ideological stance he associated with the late Rabbi Meir Kahane, and pointed to the Decisive Plan published in 2017 by Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich as a reflection of current policies.

Ayalon questioned the true meaning of democracy when majority rule is used to justify denying minority rights. He argued that damaging the right of Arab citizens to be full partners in government is a blatant repudiation of the promises made in the Declaration of Independence. He warned that this political exclusion could lead to increased violence, noting that Israel can only be a secure, Jewish, and democratic state if Arab citizens are allowed full and equal participation in all state institutions.

Citing his experience as head of the Shin Bet and a 34-year IDF commander, Ayalon noted that the agency had observed a similar process of deteriorating public confidence before the Second Intifada. He presented figures from a 2026 Israel Democracy Institute survey to illustrate the crisis of confidence, stating that only 7% of Arab Israelis trusted the government and just 5% had confidence in the prime minister. Additionally, he highlighted that approximately 75% of Arab respondents supported including Arab parties in government, while 71% of Jewish respondents opposed such participation.

Addressing the high voter turnout among Arab citizens in recent elections, Ayalon rejected the notion that this was primarily driven by violent incidents during the election period. He argued that the surge in voting was fueled by anger and a desire to claim the rights promised to them. He also referenced the Or Commission, which investigated the October 2000 events where 13 Arab citizens were killed, noting its conclusion that state institutions had failed to recognize Arabs as equal members of society.

Ayalon used the landmark Ka'adan case, in which the High Court recognized an Arab family's right to equal access to state land in Katzir, to demonstrate that legal rulings do not always translate into practical changes on the ground. He urged Israelis to embrace a version of Judaism that emphasizes compassion, equality, and the dignity of the human being, rather than the current political narrative. He reminded the audience that Israel had recently been a sovereign state and that its people had recently been strangers, urging them not to treat others as foreigners.

In his concluding remarks, Ayalon called on Israeli civil society to take responsibility for the country's democratic future. He maintained that fulfilling the promise of partnership made to Arab citizens is essential for preserving Israel's security and its Jewish-democratic identity, asserting that society as a whole holds the ultimate responsibility for this outcome.