Peter Van Dyke, the brother of legendary California surfer Kurt Van Dyke, stated on Thursday that he never lost hope that the individuals responsible for his brother's death would be brought to justice. This sentiment was expressed as Costa Rican authorities completed a nine-month investigation that initially appeared to be a simple home invasion.

Kurt Van Dyke, who was 66 years old at the time of his death, was found in February inside his apartment in the town of Hone Creek, located in Cahuita, Limón. Local authorities identified his girlfriend, referred to only as Arroyo, as a suspect in the case. She was formally arrested on November 12.

During an interview with Fox News, Peter Van Dyke described his brother as a very giving, kind, and generous person. He revealed that he was not previously aware that Kurt was in a relationship with Arroyo. Peter noted that he had only known his brother's former wife, with whom he still maintains contact, and that Kurt's children frequently stay with him.

Throughout the lengthy investigation, Peter maintained that his nephew, Kurt's son, had been in regular communication with local authorities. He said they assured the family that they had a solid case but needed time to build it properly and navigate the judicial system before making arrests.

The timeline of the case began on February 14, 2026, when Kurt was discovered dead underneath a bed in his apartment. He was wrapped in a sheet and had sustained several stab wounds, along with signs of asphyxiation. On the same day, his girlfriend told police that armed intruders had broken into the residence, restrained her, and stolen valuable items.

Investigations initially launched on February 16 and 17 treated the incident as an apparent home invasion. However, the breakthrough came on November 12, when the Costa Rica Judicial Investigation Agency arrested Arroyo, who was 31 years old at the time, and a 34-year-old man identified as Gutiérrez. According to La Nación, authorities stated that Arroyo helped the armed attackers gain entry to the apartment on the day of the murder.

Police believe that Arroyo and Gutiérrez planned a robbery targeting Kurt with the specific intent of stealing the bank card codes associated with a hotel he owned in the country. During the November raids, law enforcement seized a cellphone, a vehicle allegedly used during the crime, and other relevant items.

Officials also indicated that a gang likely staged the theft of Arroyo's car to make the incident appear like a standard robbery. This detail supports the theory that she was involved in planning the attack. Both Arroyo and Gutiérrez have been referred to Costa Rica's Public Ministry, which will now decide if formal charges are filed.