A high profile dispute has emerged in Indiana Senate District 45, where both the Republican incumbent and the local Democratic Party have requested a recount of the election results. The race between Senator Chris Garten and Democratic challenger Nick Marshall ended with a margin of fewer than 300 votes across Clark and parts of Floyd County. This narrow outcome has prompted intense scrutiny of the voting process, particularly after technical difficulties were reported at several polling locations in Clark County.

The Clark County Election Board previously decided not to count ballots cast at Jeffersonville High School, a location that experienced significant issues on Election Day. This decision sparked concerns among local Democrats regarding the accuracy of the final tallies. In response, Miguel Hampton, the chair of the Clark County Democratic Party, filed a petition on Wednesday seeking a manual recount of all 86 voting precincts within the district. Hampton argued that the votes were not correctly counted and returned due to discrepancies caused by malfunctioning equipment.

Specific technical problems cited in the filing include a jammed ballot scanner at Jeffersonville High School that required replacement, as well as issues with poll pads at three or more other sites. Hampton’s petition notes that it remains unclear whether every ballot cast at the high school was counted exactly once and how the results from the two machines were combined. The filing also requests that the recount be consolidated with the one requested by the Republican side and calls for a special election if the winner cannot be determined with certainty.

Senator Garten also filed his own petition on Tuesday, requesting a manual recount of four specific precincts in Jeffersonville. In his filing, Garten stated that he was taking this action to ensure election integrity was not treated as a political talking point. He noted that information from the election board and statements from the opposing campaign suggested votes in those areas may have been incorrectly handled. Although Garten had previously dismissed some Democratic concerns as political theater, his petition formally challenged the accuracy of the counts in the affected areas.

Legal battles accompanied the recount requests. Hampton filed a lawsuit on Monday seeking to delay the certification of election results for the Senate seat and a closely contested county auditor race. A judge initially granted a temporary restraining order to prevent Garten from being sworn in, but the Indiana Supreme Court lifted that ruling. Garten was subsequently sworn in on Tuesday during the legislature’s Organization Day and elected as Senate President Pro Tempore.

The delay in certification has left Clark County Clerk Ryan Lynch in a difficult position. The deadline for his office to certify and send the total to the state was Monday, but a court order prevented him from doing so. Lynch stated that his office is ready to certify the results and is asking the court for permission to complete the process. His attorney, Larry Wilder, described the clerk as being caught in the middle, emphasizing that the office takes no position on who should win and simply wants to follow the law.

In the county auditor race, Republican Monty Snelling defeated Democrat Antonio Veals by 257 votes. Hampton has also filed for a recount in that contest. Special Judge Jason Mount has recused himself from the case following a request by Garten, and online filings indicate that a new judge has not yet been assigned. The Indiana Recount Commission is expected to meet in Indianapolis on Monday to address these petitions, while state staff will begin sorting through ballot information in Southern Indiana on Tuesday.

Attorney Mickey Weber, who represents the Democratic Party, argued that Garten’s public comments on the issue have been misleading. Weber stated that the timing and nature of the requests make it difficult to view the actions as anything other than intentional. The legal team is focused on securing a hearing to determine if the winner can be definitively identified through a recount, with a special election serving as the next step if the results remain inconclusive.