A senior doctor whose expert evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients by his own hospital while her trial was still under way, over fears he posed a risk to patient safety, a Guardian investigation has revealed. Neither the jury nor Letby's defence team was ever told.
Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a specialist in hormones in children, was central to the prosecution's argument that Letby had poisoned babies by injecting insulin into intravenous fluid bags. Lead prosecutor Nick Johnson KC described him to jurors as 'the pre-eminent expert' on insulin.
In March 2023, five months before the trial ended at Manchester crown court, University College London hospitals trust (UCLH) excluded Hindmarsh from clinical practice. UCLH medical director Dr Tim Hodgson told the General Medical Council (GMC), the doctors' regulator, that the trust could not 'accept the level of risk Professor Hindmarsh appears to pose to children and young people.'
The GMC, already investigating Hindmarsh's fitness to practise, applied for his registration to be suspended, a step that could have led to his evidence in the ongoing trial being dismissed. In April 2023 an independent medical practitioners tribunal decided suspension would be disproportionate and instead ordered that he be directly supervised. The ruling had no practical effect, because UCLH had already stopped him practising.
Hindmarsh had told Cheshire constabulary in December 2022 that he was under GMC investigation, and the Crown Prosecution Service passed that to the defence in February 2023. But her lawyers were never told that his hospital later barred him on safety grounds, or of the April tribunal ruling. Had they known, they could have challenged his credibility and applied for his evidence to be excluded.
The GMC opened its investigation on 25 November 2022, the day Hindmarsh first gave evidence. Great Ormond Street hospital had reported 'multiple and wide-ranging concerns' about his diagnosis and treatment of patients, and had terminated his honorary consultant contract in July 2022, something jurors never heard when he confirmed in court that he held the role.
Documents seen by the Guardian show Hodgson told the regulator that Hindmarsh had breached the supervision order by independently advising on three child patients, two involving insulin and diabetes. One child later had an episode of diabetic ketoacidosis, a life-threatening complication caused by a severe lack of insulin, though Hodgson said it was not clear whether this coincided with the alleged advice.
Hodgson also reported that Hindmarsh had questioned the reliability of an insulin antibodies blood test, sharing 'his concern with the family that this was an erroneous, fallible test.' At trial, Johnson had presented immunoassay blood test results as definitive, saying there was 'no doubt' two babies were poisoned.
Letby, a former neonatal nurse at the Countess of Chester hospital, was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven more, and is serving 15 whole-life terms. She has always maintained her innocence, and her lawyer Mark McDonald has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC). Seven experts have filed reports contesting Hindmarsh's opinions, and a 14-member panel convened by Canadian neonatologist Dr Shoo Lee found unanimously that the babies died or collapsed from natural causes and poor care, with no evidence of insulin poisoning or deliberate harm. A two-year public inquiry chaired by Lady Justice Thirlwall reported in September on the basis that Letby was guilty, refusing to consider claims of a miscarriage of justice.
Rules introduced in 2014 require expert witnesses to disclose anything that might reasonably undermine their credibility, including disciplinary proceedings. Tim Green KC, a disclosure specialist, told the Guardian the duty is 'a continuous one' that runs to the end of proceedings and arguably to the CCRC's current considerations. Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian's questions. Disclosure failures are recognised as potential grounds for a CCRC referral and for convictions to be overturned.







