Former officials from the U.S. Commerce Department have described the tenure of Secretary Howard Lutnick as a period marked by significant disarray and a notable failure to enforce bans on the export of advanced computer chips to China. According to these former staff members, the department struggled with chaotic management styles and an apparent reluctance to utilize available national security tools to track sensitive technology.
The Commerce Department holds a primary responsibility for investigating and enforcing restrictions on the export of advanced chips used in artificial intelligence and sophisticated weapons to U.S. adversaries. One former official characterized the past year as having an inexplicable refusal to use the department's enforcement mechanisms for national security purposes. This internal critique has gained traction in recent days amid heightened scrutiny of Nvidia and its leadership following reports of an affair between the company's CEO and a woman believed by intelligence agencies to be a Chinese spy.
Four former Commerce officials spoke to CBS News on condition of anonymity, citing fears of professional reprisals. They alleged that the addition of entities to the federal Entity List, which bans firms from purchasing the most advanced chips, was effectively halted. One employee noted that no companies were added to this list for an entire year, a gap that had not occurred in eighteen years. The Federal Register confirms the last additions were made in October 2025, with the previous similar hiatus dating back to 2008.
Enforcement officers within the agency reportedly identified suspicious activity at facilities in Southeast Asia where Nvidia chips had been delivered. Despite these findings, directors allegedly took no immediate action to place these entities on the restricted list. This list is designed to trigger stricter license requirements and raise the threshold for preventing sensitive products from reaching unintended destinations. Instead, former staff stated that the situation was left unaddressed.
The context for these alleged failures includes a shift in policy under the current administration. In 2022 and 2023, the previous administration issued export controls on AI chips, followed by an interim rule in January 2025 to block adversaries from obtaining the most advanced technology. In May 2025, the Commerce Department under Lutnick rolled back that rule, arguing it would stifle American innovation. The department stated it would instead rely on guidance to the industry rather than strict regulatory additions.
External reports suggest that these looser controls may have been exploited. A study by the AI research nonprofit Epoch in April 2026 estimated that between 290,000 and 1.6 million cutting-edge AI chips were smuggled into China between 2024 and 2025. This volume represented roughly a quarter of the computing power China acquired through legal channels or domestic production. Additionally, reports indicated that billions of dollars worth of Nvidia chips may have reached Chinese companies through intermediaries linked to the suspected spy.
Internal communication breakdowns were also highlighted by former staff. One official recalled learning about a policy pivot to allow the sale of Nvidia's H20 and H200 chips to China through media reports rather than internal briefings. The decision was described as being made between the President and the Nvidia CEO, leaving staff to discover the change through a New York Times article.
The department has also experienced a significant loss of talent. Shortly after Lutnick took office, two senior experts, Matthew Borman and Eileen Albanese, departed their long-standing roles. Their exits were reported in February 2025, and former staff described them as treasures of the government who possessed deep institutional memory. Over the past eighteen months, up to fifty skilled staff members have left, including key experts in chips, export control, and foreign policy.
Current vacancies in the Bureau of Industry and Security, which oversees export controls, include the principal deputy assistant secretary for export administration and the chief of staff. Former employees accused Jeffrey Kessler, a top deputy to Lutnick, of micromanaging the bureau and blocking enforcement actions. They described a culture where minor decisions required approval from Kessler, who preferred to receive packaged options for higher decision makers rather than making choices himself.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent recently voiced frustration with the Commerce Department's internal processes, stating that the agency failed to follow through on chip ban enforcement despite support from other parts of the administration. Bessent noted that while the Commerce Department holds the pen for these decisions, the frustration stems from the clear directive that China should not receive Nvidia chips above a certain level of sophistication.







