Rome, Italy, witnessed the final parliamentary approval of legislation designed to intensify the national effort against antisemitism on Tuesday. The bill passed the Lower House with a vote of 147 to 93, while five lawmakers chose to abstain. Although the measure has cleared the last legislative hurdle, it has ignited a significant controversy concerning the potential boundary between anti-Jewish sentiment and valid political criticism of the State of Israel.
Proponents of the legislation argue that it is a crucial response to a marked increase in antisemitic incidents across the country. They contend that the bill will strengthen existing mechanisms for identifying and addressing anti-Jewish prejudice. Conversely, critics maintain that by adopting a widely used international definition, the law may inadvertently constrain protected political speech concerning Israel and the Palestinian people.
The significance of this debate has grown in the period following the Hamas attack on Israel in October 2023 and the subsequent war in Gaza. These events have contributed to a surge in reported antisemitic cases throughout Europe. They have also intensified a contentious discussion about the point at which criticism of Israel transitions into antisemitism.
The new legislation does not introduce new criminal offenses or penalties. Instead, it establishes guiding principles for implementing Italy's current strategy against antisemitism. A key component of the bill is its formal reference to the working definition of antisemitism adopted by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, commonly known as the IHRA.
Mario Venezia, president of the Rome Shoah Museum Foundation and a supporter of the bill, clarified that the law does not restrict criticism of Israeli policies. He noted that proposals for criminal sanctions were dropped during parliamentary discussions. Venezia described the bill as a political commitment to fighting antisemitism rather than a punitive tool, stating that while questioning the existence of the State of Israel is a different matter, criticism of the government remains accepted and encouraged.
Anneliese Baldaccini, a senior policy official at Amnesty International Italy, expressed concern that anchoring the law to the IHRA definition is the primary issue. She explained that Amnesty has long opposed the adoption of this definition because some of its examples could be interpreted to limit political expression protected by international human rights law. Baldaccini cited instances abroad, particularly in university settings, where the definition was allegedly used to suppress debate on Israel and the Palestinians.
The dispute reflects a broader international conversation regarding the IHRA definition, which characterizes antisemitism as a perception of Jews that may be expressed as hatred. The definition includes examples such as denying Jews the right to self-determination, comparing Israeli policies to those of Nazi Germany, and holding Jews collectively responsible for Israel's actions. Angelo Bonelli, co-leader of the left-wing Alleanza Verdi e Sinistra party, voted against the legislation, labeling it a gag law.
Opposition parties have advocated for the 2021 Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism as an alternative. Drafted by scholars including many Israeli experts, this declaration aims to distinguish more clearly between antisemitism and criticism of Israel. It states that support for boycotts, criticism of Zionism as a form of nationalism, and evidence-based critique of policies are not inherently antisemitic. However, the issue has divided the opposition, with PD senator Filippo Sensi calling the new bill balanced and reassuring that no one would be prosecuted for strong criticism of the Israeli government.
Giulio Terzi di Sant'Agata, a senator from Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's Fratelli d'Italia party, dismissed concerns about the law limiting freedom of speech or political opinions. Beyond the definition, the legislation outlines a three-year national strategy that includes monitoring incidents, addressing online hate, and promoting education on antisemitism.
The approval comes at a time when antisemitic incidents in Italy remain at historically high levels. The CDEC Foundation's Antisemitism Observatory recorded 963 incidents in 2025, a figure approximately 10 percent higher than the previous year. This number is more than double the 2023 total and five times the level seen in 2022. Researchers indicate that similarly elevated levels have persisted into 2026. While thousands of entities globally, including the US State Department, have recognized the IHRA definition, the US Congress has not, highlighting the ongoing global division on this topic.







