Josh Hokit came up just short of winning the UFC heavyweight championship on Saturday night, dropping a narrow unanimous decision to champion Ciryl Gane at UFC 334 at Madison Square Garden in New York. Days later, the challenger is campaigning for a rematch, pointing to an unpunished eye poke in the opening round as a decisive factor in the defeat.

Early in the first round, Gane reached toward Hokit's face and a finger clearly went into Hokit's eye. Hokit reacted to the foul, but referee Marc Goddard did not see the incident, and Gane was not punished.

Hokit pressed on and many observers felt he had done enough to win, using relentless pressure that forced Gane out of his comfort zone as a tactical striker. The judges instead favored Gane's striking edge, leaving Hokit without the belt just over one year after making his Octagon debut.

On Tuesday, Hokit responded to a video of former middleweight champion Robert Whittaker breaking down the fight, calling for an immediate rematch in posts directed at the UFC and promotion CEO Dana White.

"He completely poked my eye out 40 [seconds] into the fight," Hokit wrote. "I complained and got no help. Blinded, I had every excuse to walk away and blow up the entire event. But I didn't quit on you, and I didn't quit on the fans." He added, "Most people know I won that night. Thats why I am making the case that we should run it back."

Hokit also argued that the scoring criteria of the Unified Rules of Mixed Martial Arts should have produced a verdict in his favor. "Judges score on effective striking and impact, not patting someone with light, non damaging touches," he wrote, claiming Gane sprinted away from him for three straight rounds while he stalked the champion down and landed the heavier shots. Hokit said his coaches believed he was winning going into the fifth round, while Gane's corner told the champion he needed a knockout.

Hokit pointed out that had Gane been deducted a point for the first-round foul, he would have earned at least a draw. It is unclear whether Goddard would have taken a point had he seen the poke, but Gane has likely lost the benefit of the doubt when it comes to bending the rules.

Gane has a history of eye pokes and illegal blows, most infamously at UFC 321, when he poked then-champion Tom Aspinall in both eyes so severely that Aspinall eventually vacated the title. Gane won the interim belt in Aspinall's absence and was later elevated to undisputed champion.

Hokit closed his case by arguing that the division offers few fresh options for the champion, who has already fought nearly every contender of note. "Almost any fight you make with Ciryl right now is a recycled rematch anyway, whether it's Volkov or Alex," he wrote. "But our war was the best by a mile, and the fans deserve a definitive answer without a finger in my eye that had me seeing triple, 40 seconds into the fight. I earned this."