A Baton Rouge judge is expected to rule on a motion to dismiss rape charges against Desmond Carter in the high-profile Madison Brooks case on Monday, Nov. 23. The decision follows a dispute in which defense attorneys accused prosecutors of improperly sharing restricted video evidence with television personality Nancy Grace.

During a hearing held on Thursday, Judge Gail Horne Ray indicated that she required additional time to review motions filed by both sides. She determined that a thorough examination of the legal arguments would take until early next week before a final ruling could be issued.

Carter is set to stand trial for the alleged sexual assault of Madison Brooks, a 19-year-old student at Louisiana State University who died in January 2023. The defense filed a motion earlier this month requesting that all charges against Carter be dismissed. The attorneys argued that prosecutors shared evidence that could unduly influence potential jurors. Alternatively, the defense asked the court to exclude any evidence discussed on Grace’s national program from the trial.

The controversy stems from an episode of Grace’s podcast that aired on Oct. 29. In that broadcast, she claimed to have viewed video footage captured on the night of the alleged sexual assault. The defense contends that access to these recordings is strictly limited by a court order. The East Baton Rouge District Attorney’s Office has classified the videos as contraband, which means defense attorneys are only permitted to review them during supervised appointments.

Joe Long, an attorney representing another defendant in the case, told WAFB that he believes someone associated with the prosecution provided the recordings to Grace. Long stated that the action was taken with the intent to poison the jury pool five weeks before the trial was scheduled to begin.

Hillar Moore, the East Baton Rouge District Attorney, denied the allegations. He characterized the defense motion as a baseless attempt to delay the proceedings. Moore told WAFB that no one in his office had released any videos to anyone, including lawyers associated with the victim or her parents.

WAFB reached out to representatives for Grace’s program following the allegations but had not received a response as of its report on Nov. 5. The case remains one of the most closely watched in the region, with significant public interest in the handling of digital evidence.

Madison Brooks died on Jan. 15, 2023, after being struck by a vehicle on Burbank Drive. The incident occurred after she had spent the night in the Tigerland area near the LSU campus. Investigators alleged that Brooks was sexually assaulted inside a vehicle after leaving a bar with four men. Four individuals were arrested in connection with the investigation.

Sources previously informed WAFB Chief Investigator Chris Nakamoto that crime lab testing did not detect the DNA of any of the suspects inside Brooks. Consequently, video recordings remain a critical component of the prosecution’s case. Carter, who was 17 years old at the time of the incident, is being tried as an adult on first-degree and third-degree rape charges.

If the judge does not dismiss the case, Carter’s jury trial remains scheduled to begin on Dec. 7, according to a previous court order. The outcome of the upcoming ruling will determine the next phase in this lengthy legal battle.