A new study has raised concerns that the Internal Revenue Service has been systematically reducing tax deductions for American landowners through a conservation easement program. The research, conducted by Infinity Advisory Services, reviewed more than 130 IRS valuation cases. In 115 instances where comparable figures were available, the agency reduced the appraised values of donated rights by an average of 97 percent. Reductions of 99 percent or more were common in the data.

The conservation easement incentive allows landowners to claim a charitable deduction for permanently giving up certain development rights on their property. This process helps preserve farmland, forests, and other protected areas. While landowners retain ownership, they accept restrictions on how the land can be developed. The value of these donated rights is determined by an appraisal, which serves as the basis for the tax deduction.

The authors of the study argue that the pattern of reductions across different properties and tax years suggests a predetermined outcome. They believe the process was designed to reach a specific conclusion rather than fairly evaluating each property. In the executive summary, the authors stated that the record is consistent with the view that the government's position was settled as a matter of policy before being tested against the facts of individual cases.

A former IRS valuator with many years of experience at the agency told Fox News Digital that he witnessed officials pressuring appraisers to reach predetermined conclusions. The whistleblower said the agency often brushed aside evidence from taxpayers who donated development rights. He described a culture where the IRS is focused on maximizing revenue, noting that the agency is setting up taxpayers it knows are innocent. He added that the application of the law appears slanted, and that valuation issues should be handled by experts rather than through a biased process.

One case highlighted in the study involved a historic building in Cleveland. An IRS reviewer initially valued a donated preservation easement at between 18.1 million and 23.2 million dollars. In a follow-up review, the value was reduced to 400,000 dollars, which significantly increased the landowner's tax burden. The revised report cited instructions from IRS counsel to exclude certain development rights from consideration. The study authors argue this reversal reflected a directive for a class of properties rather than new evidence about the specific building.

The whistleblower also cited a case where the IRS identified eight areas of concern but refused to hear the taxpayer's explanations. When the taxpayer offered to address each point, an IRS Appeals technical advisor reportedly said, I don't want to hear it. The mediation ended without an agreement. The whistleblower noted that this exchange exemplifies the agency's unwillingness to fairly consider taxpayer evidence. He emphasized that the issues should be viewed from a factual and nonpartisan perspective.

Steve Moore, chairman and co-founder of Unleash Prosperity, recently argued that the IRS crackdown has swept up honest taxpayers who relied on qualified appraisers. Moore stated that while there are cases of fraud involving fraudulent appraisals, the IRS is throwing the baby out with the bathwater by treating everyone the same. He said he has heard from numerous families across the country who feel victimized by the process. Moore expressed frustration that the IRS has not fully addressed the concerns, noting that some people may go bankrupt as a result.

In August, the IRS acknowledged in a press release that standardized settlement offers were not well suited for all conservation easement cases. The agency ended that initiative and announced the creation of a new Office of Conservation Easements. However, the announcement did not address the central questions of whether the agency fairly considered taxpayer evidence or if its valuations were predetermined. The IRS directed media inquiries to this August press release when contacted for comment on the new study.

The IRS has recently secured significant court victories in conservation easement disputes. In July, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a decision valuing an easement over 103 acres in Georgia at 480,000 dollars, compared to a claimed deduction of 23 million dollars. The court rejected the proposed quarry development as economically unviable and upheld a 40 percent penalty. In August, the same court upheld a 900,000 dollar valuation for another Georgia easement where an 8.9 million dollar deduction had been claimed. The Tax Court has also repeatedly rejected IRS efforts to impose civil fraud penalties in similar cases.