A man was arrested last Friday in connection with a 2023 overdose death in Richmond, Kentucky, following a new statement from the victim’s girlfriend earlier this month. Justin Kavanaugh, 43, faces one count of second-degree manslaughter and one count of first-degree trafficking in a controlled substance involving fentanyl.

The investigation began after Steven Toler was discovered dead on Dec. 14, 2023, inside a truck at his mother’s home in the 100 block of Janwell Drive. According to court records, Toler’s girlfriend told the officer who responded that a day had passed without anyone hearing from him. She said that she and Toler had argued about his alleged drug use before that period without contact.

Investigators subsequently received information from Toler’s mother about a drug purchase. She told officers that her son had bought drugs from someone known as “Jay.” At that point, the substance he had reportedly purchased was suspected to be methamphetamine, according to the account in court records.

Police examined information on Toler’s phone and recognized the telephone number associated with “Jay.” Court records say officers knew the number belonged to Kavanaugh because of an earlier investigation. That connection was one of the links investigators established as they worked to determine who had supplied Toler with drugs.

Another link involved a piece of paper recovered from the cab of Toler’s truck. Investigators identified it as a cash-out receipt from Red Mile Gaming and believed it had served as packaging for the drugs. The receipt was also connected to Kavanaugh. Even with the phone number and the receipt, however, investigators lacked definitive evidence that he had actually given Toler the drugs.

Earlier in November, Toler’s girlfriend supplied investigators with a written statement describing an encounter before his death. She is currently incarcerated in connection with a separate matter. According to court records, she said she witnessed Kavanaugh pass Toler a folded piece of paper after the two men had gotten high on methamphetamine.

Her account of seeing that exchange provided a key breakthrough in the case. It added a reported observation of contact between Kavanaugh and Toler to an investigation that had previously linked Kavanaugh to the phone number and the paper recovered from the truck.