US Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby has offered a critical assessment of Ukraine's long-range strike campaign against Russian territory. Speaking at the opening of the 37th meeting of the Ukraine Defence Contact Group, commonly known as the Ramstein format, Colby suggested that attacks on civilian infrastructure have not achieved their strategic goals. He stated that such strikes may have inadvertently strengthened both Russian public resolve and the Kremlin's willingness to escalate the conflict.

Colby noted that while public discourse often centers on the dramatic nature of deep strikes intended to inflict pain on the Russian population, the Pentagon's internal assessment indicates a different outcome. According to the official, these operations have not been effective in driving an end to the war. Furthermore, he argued that they have not contributed to blunting Russian advances on the front line.

The Under Secretary specifically cited strikes on facilities he classified as civilian infrastructure, including the Wildberries retail network, as examples that may have hardened Russian societal attitudes. He emphasized that these actions could also increase the Kremlin's own inclination to escalate military measures. This perspective highlights a potential divergence between the perceived symbolic impact of deep strikes and their actual military utility.

In his remarks, Colby also addressed the broader balance of power in long-range engagements. He suggested that the advantage in this specific domain of warfare may currently favor Moscow. However, he was careful to clarify that his comments were not intended to limit Ukraine's operational freedom. He stated that Ukraine should not be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back, indicating that the US does not seek to impose strict restrictions on Kyiv's ability to wage war.

Instead, Colby proposed a shift in the focus of Western support. He argued that the primary objective should be enabling and advancing Ukraine's capacity to hold the line of battle and, where possible, make territorial gains. Support directed at strikes focused on the front line and direct assistance to that battle area, he noted, falls squarely into this category of priority.

Despite his critical view of strikes on civilian targets, Colby acknowledged that attacks on facilities that directly enable Russia to wage war can still be valuable. He recognized that these specific types of strikes can help contribute to slowing Russian advances on the front lines. This distinction underscores a strategic preference for targeting military logistics and combat capabilities over civilian infrastructure.

Colby's statements come amid ongoing discussions about the scope of Ukraine's air campaign. Earlier on November 17, NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte commented on Ukraine's strike on the Crimean Bridge. Rutte affirmed that Ukraine has the right to defend itself, including by targeting Russian logistical hubs, which aligns with the broader context of international support for Kyiv's defensive and offensive operations.

The remarks from the Pentagon's policy chief add a new layer to the debate over the use of long-range weapons. In August 2025, the Wall Street Journal reported that the Pentagon had been blocking Ukraine's long-range strikes on Russian territory for months. At that time, it was reported that Colby had developed a mechanism for reviewing Kyiv's requests to use US long-range weapons, as well as weapons supplied by European allies whose use depends on US intelligence or components.

This review process has been a point of contention in recent months. Colby's current comments at the Ramstein meeting provide further insight into the Pentagon's strategic thinking regarding the war in Ukraine. As the conflict continues, the balance between striking deep into enemy territory and consolidating gains on the front line remains a central focus of allied coordination.

The 37th meeting of the Ukraine Defence Contact Group serves as a key forum for coordinating military and political support. Colby's address sets the tone for these discussions, emphasizing a pragmatic approach to warfare that prioritizes frontline stability. His words reflect a nuanced view that seeks to balance the psychological impact of deep strikes with the tangible needs of ground forces.