Ahead of the 2026 NFL Draft, the Tennessee Titans were widely expected to select a defensive player with the fourth overall pick. With a new head coach focused on defense, interest in Ohio State pass rushers Arvell Reese and Sonny Styles seemed logical. Speculation also surrounded Notre Dame running back Jeremiyah Love. However, the team had recently signed free agent wide receiver Wan Dale Robinson and re-signed veteran Calvin Ridley, which led to loose rumors that Ohio State wide receiver Carnell Tate might be taken earlier than anticipated.

When Commissioner Roger Goodell announced the selection in Pittsburgh, he called the name of Tate. The Buckeyes star had recorded 51 receptions for 875 yards and nine touchdowns in his final collegiate season alongside phenom Jeremiah Smith. The choice was likely driven by the ownership's desire to support quarterback Cam Ward, mirroring the previous plan to evaluate Will Levis. If the goal was to bolster the passing game, the question remains whether Tate was the optimal choice at such a high position.

Tate has shown promise but has been hindered by four drops and three fumbles. He excels in zone coverage and has a strong feel for spacing in the short to intermediate areas of the field. However, he has yet to demonstrate consistent success against man coverage or the ability to stretch the field. According to Next Gen Stats, he has only one reception for 33 yards on eight targets with 20 or more air yards. He ranks 42nd in expected points added per target against man coverage among 53 receivers with at least 10 such targets.

The Titans likely sought a player with size who could align as an X or Z receiver. Jordyn Tyson was not available until Week 9, while Denzel Boston has shown inconsistent production. Comparisons to Jaxon Smith-Njigba are possible, as both faced questions about their ceilings. Smith-Njigba started with 63 receptions for 628 yards and four touchdowns as a rookie. Tate is currently on pace for 77 receptions for 944 yards. The team will see if his usage changes following a recent bye week.

Historical data suggests that the first wide receiver drafted does not always become the most productive. In recent years, players like Malik Nabers outperformed Marvin Harrison Jr., and Tetairoa McMillan has been a better receiver than Travis Hunter Jr. In 2019, A.J. Brown and other stars went undrafted in the first round despite high-profile picks like Hollywood Brown and N'Keal Harry. Justin Jefferson is another example, having been the fifth wide receiver taken in his class.

The Titans also traded up from the 35th pick to select Auburn edge rusher Keldric Faulk at No. 31. Head coach Saleh likely wanted to add defensive talent after using the No. 4 pick on offense. Faulk, a young prospect with excellent size and length, had not fully realized his potential in college. By drafting him late in the first round, the team hopes to develop his skills and acquire talent that should have been available earlier.

To date, Faulk has struggled to get off blocks and often attempts to play through the body of opponents, a tactic that requires significant strength to succeed against NFL linemen. His 2.8 percent pressure rate ranks 26th among 27 rookies with at least 50 pass rush snaps, according to TruMedia. In comparison, the three pass rushers selected after him rank much higher in this metric: Mason Thomas is fifth, Cashius Howell is seventh, and T.J. Parker is 12th.

Faulk's difficulties extend to the run game, where he often gets stuck in the body of blockers and struggles to disengage. He has four run tackles and three run stops through 89 running downs this season. His 4.5 percent run tackle rate and 3.4 percent run stop rate rank 54th and 46th, respectively, among 56 rookies with at least 50 run downs, per Next Gen Stats.

Looking ahead, Tate's baseline profile suggests a high-end number two receiver with the potential to become a top 20 player in the league. His early struggles with fumbles and drops may be aberrations, as he had only five drops and zero fumbles in 39 college games at Ohio State. Faulk, who recently turned 22, allows the Titans to be patient. However, history indicates that slow starters rarely become elite performers unless they possess a specific winning trait while other aspects of their game develop.