Spain has released James Chambers, a wealthy American activist, on bail as part of the Trump administration's bid to extradite him to the United States. The release occurred on Friday, coinciding with a separate police operation in which Irish authorities raided a Dublin residence owned by Chambers and his partner, Stella Schnabel. Irish police acted on a request from US authorities during the search.
This case marks the first known instance of the United States seeking to extradite a citizen based on alleged support for Hamas. The accusations are linked to an international money-laundering charge within the criminal complaint and donations to organizations assisting Palestinians in Gaza. Upon his release outside Madrid's Aranjuez prison, Chambers described the charges against him as baseless. He expressed hope that his release was the first step toward international recognition of that view.
Chambers stated that Spain had stood on the right side of the issue, referring to the ongoing conflict as a genocide. He added that the situation now reflects some reason and justice. An appeals court ordered his conditional release due to problems with the legally required Spanish translation of the core extradition documents. Chambers had been detained since July 10, following his arrest in Ibiza.
The court order noted that the translation issues cause a diminishment in the solidity of the extradition request for the time being. This decision followed a move on Thursday by a three-judge panel at the high court to pause proceedings. The judges are evaluating the impact of alterations made by the US to the original machine-generated translation.
The Guardian previously detailed four examples of these alterations on November 7. The US admitted to tampering with the translation on November 17, describing the changes as substantial and inadvertent. Chambers's defense team has asserted for weeks that there are as many as 30 such alterations. Aitor Martínez, a member of the defense team, told the Guardian that the changes introduced prejudicial notions with specific legal implications. These notions eventually appeared in the Spanish prosecutor's report on the case.
The high court had expected to rule on the extradition this week after a hearing on November 13. However, the deadline has been extended indefinitely while the judges assess the translation. The defense team submitted a 345-page report identifying 30 incriminating changes made to a translation prepared by DeepL, an AI-first translation platform. The decision also allows the prosecutor to address the issue in writing, after previously dismissing it by referring to supposed translation errors.
Chambers, the heir to a $250m family business, Cox Enterprises, has been extensively profiled in US media for his views and donations to progressive and humanitarian projects. His defense team has argued that he is being sought for extradition because of such views. A week after the Hamas attacks on Israel in October 2023, he posted on X that Israel's response was simply genocide, arguing that no faction of the Palestinian resistance had done anything wrong.
Meanwhile, the Irish Garda Síochána raided the Dublin house on Wednesday. According to their attorney in Ireland, Ciarán Mulholland, police destroyed the front door and removed electronic items and other possessions. Schnabel, who is five months pregnant, described the raid as a desperate fishing expedition by US authorities to find evidence to bolster their case against Chambers.
Mulholland stated that the raid resulted from a mutual legal assistance request, which he argued would not typically give Irish police permission to kick in the doors of a dwelling. He called the state's clandestine manner unusual and has asked authorities to produce a search warrant and an itemized list of taken items. He fears that the seized items have already been flown to the US. The attorney said the case shows a complete disregard for due process by the Trump administration.







