Three years after Governor Gavin Newsom signed legislation intended to bring individuals with severe mental illnesses and addictions into involuntary treatment, the anticipated surge in cases has not materialized. Senate Bill 43, enacted in 2023, expanded the definition of "gravely disabled" under the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act. This expansion allows courts to place more people under conservatorship, including those unable to ensure their own safety or medical care and those incapacitated by severe substance use disorders.
Data obtained by CalMatters from the state's 25 most populous counties reveals that the number of one-year mental health conservatorships has barely increased in most jurisdictions. Of the 19 counties that provided point-in-time data, 12 reported either a decrease or a rise of less than 5 percent in their caseloads. The average increase across these counties was under 6 percent, with the overall number of cases rising by just 4 percent. Toni Navarro, director of behavioral health for Santa Barbara County, noted that the impact was not as significant as initially anticipated, with her county seeing a 1 percent drop in conservatorships since the law took effect there in July 2025.
Several factors may explain the modest growth in conservatorship cases. Some counties improved voluntary mental health services around the same time the new law was implemented, leading more individuals to choose care voluntarily rather than being forced into treatment. Additionally, county behavioral health directors suggest that the legislation attempted to integrate addiction treatment into a framework designed for mental illness, which may not be an ideal fit. Despite the lower-than-expected numbers, health officials argue the law has achieved positive outcomes, such as facilitating better addiction treatment for individuals with dual diagnoses.
The personal stakes of the legislation are highlighted by the case of Joaquin Anthony "Tony" Pereyra, who was shot and killed by Walnut Creek police in February. His mother, Annis Pereyra, had been begging Contra Costa County to use the new law to compel him to take antipsychotic medication that had previously stabilized his schizophrenia. Annis stated that her son's needs were ignored at every turn, and he was not placed on the only medication that had saved him from the horrors of his illness. Tony had experienced a period of stability in his 30s after finding the right medication, but he stopped taking it in the summer of 2024 following a medical emergency involving his mother.
After a violent incident at his parents' home in March 2025, Tony was placed in locked facilities under temporary conservatorships but was released without resuming his medication. The county's attempt to reach him through CARE Court also failed. Annis believed the new conservatorship law would have made him a candidate for longer-term treatment given his inability to care for himself and recognize his need for medication. Diane Burgis, chair of the Contra Costa County board of supervisors, acknowledged that the system still has work to do, noting that the law was not as far-reaching as expected.
While some counties saw larger increases in short-term 72-hour psychiatric holds, these do not always lead to lasting treatment. For example, San Mateo County saw a quarter increase in such holds after the law took effect, and Los Angeles County wrote more than 500 holds for severe substance use disorder between January and June 2026. However, individuals on these short-term holds often cycle repeatedly between hospitals and the street. San Francisco attributed its 7 percent increase in conservatorship cases partly to the new law, which helped address risks of fatal overdoses and self-harm.
Disability rights advocates, who opposed the law, caution that it is too early to measure its full impact. Samuel Jain of Disability Rights California expects to see more people forced into involuntary treatment as more facilities are built. Senator Roger Niello, a co-author of the bill, expressed concern that society's reluctance to overrule civil rights and funding shortages are jeopardizing the law's effectiveness. He stated that without increased capacity for treatment, it is unclear if any amount of time would show success.
The case of Tony Pereyra has become a focal point for families who view the law as part of a series of unfulfilled promises by the administration. Teresa Pasquini, a mental health advocate, described the gaps in the system as scary. Contra Costa County, where Tony lived, has seen a 13 percent increase in one-year conservatorships, rising from 98 to 111 cases. Despite this, the department declined to make anyone available for an interview regarding the specific impact of the new law on his case.







