Washington, D.C., November 18, 2026. Senators are mounting a significant opposition to President Donald Trump's directive to retrofit the nation's newest aircraft carriers with older steam catapults. The order, which would replace the modern electromagnetic launch systems, is expected to cost billions of dollars and could reduce the operational capabilities of the Navy's most advanced warships.

The resistance is coming from within the president's own party, with key Republican leaders questioning the strategic and financial wisdom of the move. Senator Roger Wicker, a Republican from Mississippi and the chair of the Senate Armed Services Committee, described the plan as a nonstarter during a committee hearing. He emphasized that the military community needs to understand that reverting to steam technology is not a viable option for the future of the fleet.

This pushback coincides with the release of the 2027 defense appropriations bill, which includes provisions directed by the Senate Appropriations Committee. The bill requires the Navy to submit a report comparing the effectiveness of the new magnetically powered catapults against the traditional steam-powered systems. Republican lawmakers expressed concern in an explanatory statement that such a major redesign would lead to substantial additional costs and significant delays in the program schedule.

The controversy highlights a notable internal conflict within the Republican-controlled Congress as it nears the end of its term. Trump has long been critical of the electromagnetic system, claiming in the Oval Office last year that it did not work. He issued a memo in August ordering a return to the steam system, a stance he has maintained since his first term when he argued the new technology lacked power. This dispute occurs as the administration seeks congressional approval for a $1.5 trillion defense budget before Democrats take control of both houses of Congress on January 3.

During a hearing on Tuesday, acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao faced questions regarding his support for the president's directive. While discussing his nomination for the permanent post, Cao argued that the inclusion of the new system and electromagnetically driven elevators had delayed carrier production by seven years. He stated that his goal was to accelerate the process, a position that appeared to contrast with his earlier testimony where he halted engineering changes to the Navy's new frigates to keep that program on track.

Critics, including Democratic Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia, pointed to operational evidence from the USS Gerald R. Ford. Kaine noted that sailors on the carrier's flight deck spoke highly of the new system. He reminded the committee that the electromagnetic launch system allowed the carrier to launch more aircraft in less time using fewer personnel. Kaine, who represents the carrier's homeport and the shipyard building U.S. carriers, urged decision-makers to consider the practical experience of those operating the system before committing to a more expensive and potentially less capable path.

The Navy's own assessments have generally praised the performance and maintenance of the new systems following the Ford's recent deployment to the Middle East. However, Trump's August memo cited the Navy's constant design changes as a source of cost growth and delays, declaring that the Navy should not impose iterative changes on mature parent designs. The White House defended the president's approach, with spokesperson Olivia Wales stating that Trump has revitalized the shipbuilding industry and fixed critical long-term issues to restore maritime dominance.

The debate over launch systems also has international implications. Both the newest Chinese aircraft carriers and France's planned new carrier are set to use electromagnetic catapults. As the administration continues to evaluate the Ford-class design, which includes the possibility of canceling future versions, the clash between political preference and technical evidence remains a central issue in defense policy discussions.

Lt. Cmdr. Adagray Willis, a spokeswoman for the acting Navy Secretary, indicated that Cao intends to work with the White House, the Pentagon, Congress, and the defense industry to ensure the Navy remains the most capable in the world. The upcoming legislative battles over defense spending are likely to center on these technical and financial disagreements, with both parties seeking to define the direction of the U.S. naval fleet for the coming decades.