A federal judge has permitted significant portions of a high-stakes defamation lawsuit filed by President Trump against The New York Times and four of its senior reporters to move forward. The legal action alleges that the publication and its journalists undermined the President's candidacy ahead of the 2024 presidential election by publishing inaccurate claims regarding his financial history.
U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday issued the ruling on Thursday, determining that the newspaper may have acted with recklessness. The court found that the Times advanced allegations linking Trump to tax crimes based on what could be described as incomplete or minimal information, a finding that allows the core of the case to continue to trial.
While the court allowed seven specific statements to proceed, it dismissed 27 other statements that Trump had identified as defamatory. The surviving claims primarily revolve around allegations made in the book Lucky Loser and a related Times story. These reports suggested that Trump received approximately $400 million from his father, with much of that wealth acquired through tax evasion schemes, and that he had violated money laundering rules.
In his decision, Judge Merryday emphasized the complexity of assessing the Trump family’s compliance with tax laws. He concluded that such an assessment requires forensic auditing and expert legal advice that the defendants did not obtain. The judge noted that the facts alleged in the complaint create a plausible inference that the authors and publishers knew reliable conclusions about tax violations were impossible without qualified opinions from experts who had conducted necessary factual and legal research.
The ruling hinges on the legal standard of actual malice, which applies to defamation cases involving public officials. This standard requires a plaintiff to show that defendants knew their statements were false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth. Merryday wrote that the defendants knowingly failed to secure the necessary expert analysis, a failure that supports the claim of actual malice.
The New York Times argued in its defense that its reporters had analyzed more than 100,000 pages of financial records and consulted with several experts, including tax specialists. However, the court countered that analyzing tax and money laundering crimes is intensely fact dependent. The judge stated that only a relatively small cohort of specialized practitioners are qualified to speak on such topics.
Because the reporters did not secure an explicit opinion from a qualified source confirming that Trump had committed a crime, the court found they had a particularized reason to doubt the truth of their statements. Merryday suggested that the reporting may constitute a purposeful avoidance of the truth, a critical factor in allowing the case to advance despite the defendants' efforts to prove their diligence.
The four journalists named in the lawsuit are investigative reporters Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, who co-authored the book Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success. The other two defendants are Washington D.C. correspondent Michael S. Schmidt and White House correspondent Peter Baker. All four are accused of contributing to the alleged defamatory reporting.
The lawsuit, which seeks at least $15 billion in damages, was filed by attorney Alejandro Brito. Brito has handled other media-related lawsuits for Trump. The case represents a significant legal test for major news organizations regarding the extent of expert consultation required when reporting on complex financial and legal matters involving prominent public figures.







