The UK government is likely to miss its legally binding climate targets if it proceeds with plans to weaken electric vehicle sales rules, according to the Climate Change Committee. The advisory body stated in a letter published on Wednesday that allowing more sales of petrol and diesel cars and vans over the next four years would create a significant gap in the plan to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2050. This assessment has raised concerns that the administration led by Andy Burnham may need to lower its carbon emission reduction targets, known as carbon budgets, to account for the additional pollution.

The committee estimates that the proposed changes could result in an extra 8.4 million tonnes of CO2 pollution annually by the next decade. Because the electric vehicle mandate is the single largest contributor to the country's climate goals, any weakening of these rules would force the government to find other major sources of carbon reduction. Alternatively, the government would have to amend the existing carbon budgets to permit higher levels of pollution.

Under the current zero emission vehicle mandate, carmakers are required to sell an increasing proportion of electric vehicles each year or face fines of 12,000 pounds per vehicle. The industry has lobbied intensely for months to lower the headline targets from 80 percent electric by 2030 to between 50 and 60 percent. Manufacturers argue that the current mandate places excessive financial pressure on the sector. While electric cars accounted for 26.6 percent of new UK car sales in the first ten months of 2026, falling below the 33 percent target for that period, carmakers are expected to comply with the mandate by utilizing various regulatory loopholes referred to as flexibilities.

Nigel Topping, chair of the Climate Change Committee, wrote to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander to oppose any reduction of the targets. Topping argued that cutting the targets would put the government's commitment to tackling climate change at risk and miss an opportunity to reduce household costs by approximately 800 pounds per year. He also noted that the changes would increase the UK's exposure to volatile oil markets by up to 15 million barrels of oil annually by 2030 and damage long-term competitiveness as major export markets transition to electric vehicles.

Recent months have seen growing alarm within the government regarding the impact of various policy changes on climate commitments. The administration recently cut funding for heat pump installations, which is the second largest decarbonization policy. Additionally, Prime Minister Burnham has faced criticism from some Labour MPs for approving gas extraction from the Jackdaw gasfield and considering approval for the massive Rosebank oilfield. Earlier this year, MPs voted to approve a new set of carbon reductions for the period between 2038 and 2042.

The Guardian has learned that one cabinet minister in the Keir Starmer government previously proposed returning to parliament to scrap those planned reductions and enact a more conservative target. Although the idea did not gain traction due to opposition from other cabinet ministers, an industry source said serious consideration was still being given to changing the carbon budgets before the UN's Cop31 climate conference. A government source strongly denied that the proposal was currently under consideration, while the industry source noted it remained unclear if the discussion was still active.

The changes to the mandate mean the UK is unlikely to meet the carbon budget covering 2033 to 2037. Several analysts believe the government will struggle to find equivalent emissions reductions elsewhere given the scale of pollution from internal combustion engine vehicles. The policy may also face opposition from the devolved administrations in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, each of which maintains its own carbon budgets.

Speaking at Cop31 in Antalya, Turkey, on Thursday, Burnham said he was proud to support the conference's focus on electrification and urged people to choose electric cars and heat pumps. However, Doug Parr, chief scientist at Greenpeace UK, criticized the stance, stating that the government cannot claim climate leadership internationally while reversing ZEV targets domestically.

Topping added that weakening the mandate would undermine Britain's competitiveness and leave the country more exposed to fossil fuel price volatility. He emphasized that people are buying electric vehicles in record numbers because they are cheaper to own, and that the mandate provides the certainty needed for supply chain investment and job support. In response, the car industry criticized the committee's analysis. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society for Motor Manufacturers and Traders, argued that the CCC ignored the damaging costs of the targets, including unsustainable discounts and government incentives. He claimed the mandate is deterring local investment because a strong local market is necessary for a viable business case to build in the UK.

A government spokesperson maintained that the administration remains committed to phasing out all new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and ensuring all new car and van sales are zero emission by 2035. The spokesperson stated that the ongoing consultation on the mandate would ensure a pragmatic and balanced approach to the transition without altering these core commitments.