An atmospheric river recently delivered extreme rainfall to San Francisco, transforming streets into murky pools and causing manholes to erupt with water. While the damage this week has been significant, experts warn that conditions could worsen in the coming days. A stronger atmospheric river is forecast to impact the Bay Area just before the Thanksgiving holiday, coinciding with the highest tides of the year.
Kristina Hill, an associate professor of landscape architecture, environmental planning, and urban design at UC Berkeley, stated on Thursday that residents should anticipate more severe flooding near their homes next week. The rapid onset of the recent flooding was driven by a combination of intense precipitation, aging infrastructure, and long-term climate trends.
The sheer volume of rain was a primary factor. Wednesday marked one of the rainiest November days in the city's recorded history, which spans more than a century. Daniel Swain, a climate scientist with the University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources, noted that the city experienced one of its heaviest hourly downpours. He observed on social media that this is the third or fourth time in the current decade that San Francisco has faced a comparable event. Heated tropical waters associated with El Niño, a cycle that occurs every two to seven years and is intensified by climate change, fueled the strong winds and rain.
A second critical factor is the city's unique underground plumbing system. Unlike many other urban areas, San Francisco uses a combined system where stormwater and sewage travel through the same pipes. This design dates back to the 19th century, when engineers believed that rainwater would help flush away human waste. Hill explained that while this logic made sense at the time, it has become a significant challenge in the modern era.
Since federal environmental protection laws took effect in the 1970s, the city is no longer permitted to discharge untreated sewage directly into the bay and ocean. Consequently, when heavy rainfall overwhelms the capacity of the pipes, the water has nowhere to go but up. In certain parts of the city, this results in a health hazard as raw sewage mixes with the surface flooding. Hill suggested that the potential solution involves constructing additional tunnels or pipes to accommodate the extra volume, a strategy already implemented in cities like Chicago and Washington, D.C.
Climate change serves as the third major contributor to the problem. Two centuries of burning fossil fuels have warmed the planet, leading to melting polar ice and expanding ocean volumes. According to a state agency, water levels in the bay rose by eight inches over the last century. Projections indicate that levels could rise another ten inches by 2050. As the ocean rises, it pushes up groundwater, making low-lying neighborhoods such as the Mission District more vulnerable to flooding.
Hill's research indicates that rising groundwater levels in the Bay Area could reach thousands of contaminated sites, including areas in Richmond, West Oakland, and Hunters Point. When these factors are combined, the outlook for the upcoming week appears concerning. The arrival of a mightier atmospheric river, coupled with king tides and a city that is already saturated from this week's storm, creates a high-risk scenario. Beyond the immediate threat, the rising oceans driven by a warming world are a persistent challenge that is not expected to reverse.
Hill described sea-level rise as a situation where the horse has left the barn. She emphasized that the city has placed itself in this position and must now learn to live with the consequences. As the region prepares for the next weather system, the interplay between historical infrastructure and modern climate realities remains a central focus for urban planners and residents alike.







