The Trump administration is facing renewed scrutiny over its management of billions of dollars in oil revenue from Venezuela. Since January 3, the US government has controlled Venezuelan oil exports, depositing the proceeds into an account overseen solely by the US Treasury. A 53-page report released last week by the Department of State indicated that at least $12.11 billion has passed through this account since the beginning of the year. However, critics argue that the document lacks essential details regarding the origin of the funds and their final recipients.

Tyson Slocum, director of the energy program at the nonprofit Public Citizen, described the process as having zero transparency. He noted that while there is a basic narrative of how the funds were used, the report does not specify which entities were involved in the financial transactions. This lack of clarity has intensified since the administration began seizing oil tankers leaving Venezuela late last year, framing the confiscated fuel as compensation for past nationalizations of the industry.

Tensions peaked on January 3 when President Trump authorized a military operation to remove Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro from power. In a speech that morning, Trump stated the US would extract significant wealth from the ground and use some proceeds to reimburse the United States for damages. Legal experts have questioned the operation's legality, citing a 1962 United Nations resolution that grants nations permanent sovereignty over their natural resources. Despite these concerns, Maduro has been replaced by former Vice President Delcy Rodriguez, who has largely cooperated with US demands.

Recent agreements have further fueled speculation about the administration's intentions. In late August, Trump announced a deal giving the US majority control over 17 Venezuelan oilfields with 65 billion barrels in proven reserves. The rights to operate these fields were granted to North American Blue Energy Partners, a company owned by Venezuelan businessman Alejandro Betancourt. The Pentagon holds a 35 percent stake in the company, and the US is guaranteed 20 percent of the oil output at cost. Trump labeled this arrangement the biggest oil deal in history, though Betancourt has faced money laundering investigations in the US, Spain, and Switzerland.

Venezuelan opposition leader Maria Corina Machado stated that the contract does not reflect the transparency Venezuelan society expects. Luis A Pacheco, a former executive at Venezuela's state oil company, expressed skepticism about the deal, calling the operating company obscure and lacking financial strength. He argued that the so-called mega-deal will likely yield far less than anticipated. Pacheco also questioned the administration's claim of supervisory role, noting that while the White House speaks of tutelage, it does not disclose where the money is ultimately going.

The lack of clarity has prompted US Democrats to demand greater accountability. In September, members of both the House and Senate asked the administration to release findings from an audit conducted by the accounting firm KPMG. Although the State Department issued its report last week, key sections were redacted, including information on who deposited funds and who received them. John Feeley, a former US ambassador, noted that the $12 billion accounted for in the report may represent only a fraction of the total proceeds.

A State Department spokesperson told Al Jazeera that the report provides a comprehensive account of revenues down to the cent. The spokesperson added that disbursement requests are checked against approved expenditure categories and used for essential public services, macroeconomic stability, and infrastructure rebuilding. However, Pacheco maintained that the report still fails to illuminate the most important question: what the Venezuelan regime is doing with the money. He suggested that when dealing with billions of dollars, something is likely draining away.

This year's midterm elections have shifted the balance of power in Congress, potentially leading to increased oversight. Democrats won majority control in both chambers in the November 3 elections. Lawmakers have already floated the possibility of opening investigations once the new Congress convenes in January. Representative Joaquin Castro stated that he will use every tool available to uncover what the United States is doing in Venezuela, emphasizing that the list of beneficiaries remains murky.

One area of likely investigation is the role of private oil trading companies. Firms such as Vitol, a Dutch multinational, may face scrutiny. According to Reuters, a senior Vitol trader held a secret meeting with Vice President JD Vance in Montana a week before the military operation. Vitol subsequently purchased oil from Venezuela's state-owned company at a steep discount. The trader and his wife donated $6 million to Trump's 2024 election campaign. Representative Robert Garcia, who is expected to chair the House Oversight Committee next year, said Democrats will not stop until they know exactly which companies are profiting from these foreign policy decisions.