Two men who were initially cleared in a South Carolina road rage shooting three years ago are now facing murder charges. The new indictments follow a period of intense scrutiny by the victim's family, who uncovered evidence suggesting that local police officers influenced the original investigation. This development marks a significant shift in a case that had previously been closed without criminal charges against the suspects.

The incident in question occurred in September 2023 in Horry County. Authorities stated that Weldon Boyd and Kenneth Williams chased Scott Spivey for several miles after a road rage incident began with Spivey pulling a gun on them. Both pickup trucks reached speeds exceeding 100 mph. The pursuit ended when Spivey pulled onto a side road, exited his truck, and instructed the men to stop following him.

During this confrontation, the men fired through the windshield of Spivey's pickup. The bullet struck Spivey in the right side of his back, near his armpit, leading to his death. Initially, the local prosecutor referred the case to the South Carolina Attorney General's Office after Boyd posted a message on social media thanking police and prosecutors for their handling of the matter just one week after the shooting.

Seven months after the incident, the Attorney General's Office decided not to prosecute Boyd and Williams. At the time, the ruling stated that the men were justified in firing under the state's stand your ground law because they felt threatened. This decision prompted Spivey's family to file a civil lawsuit, which eventually led to the discovery of crucial new evidence.

Through the civil suit, the family obtained recordings of Boyd's phone calls. In these conversations, Boyd bragged about the shooting and asked a police officer friend to intervene in the investigation. He also discussed getting teardrop tattoos with Williams because they had killed a man. In another call, Boyd described the event as a blast, while also noting that Spivey had realized he could drive faster during the chase and was terrified.

The family also secured body camera footage showing an officer writing a note to the men on the day of the shooting. The note advised them to act like a victim camera. This physical evidence, combined with the audio recordings, pushed the Attorney General's Office to review the case again with the help of an outside prosecutor from Spartanburg named Barry Barnette.

Following this independent review, a new grand jury was convened. On Thursday, the jury returned indictments against all four individuals. Boyd and Williams were charged with murder, while two former Horry County officers, Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland and Sergeant Damon Vescovi, were charged with misconduct in office and obstruction of justice.

Strickland was charged after Boyd called him from the scene and later, with Boyd claiming Strickland had spoken to investigators and prosecutors. Vescovi was charged for passing along the note regarding the camera. Both officers were fired following the emergence of this new evidence.

Defense attorneys for the four men argued that publicity had tainted the case and maintained that their clients were innocent. Shaun Kent, Boyd's lawyer, contended that the charges should be dropped because evidence from the civil case was used to build the criminal case, a tactic similar to one that led to the dismissal of charges against Bill Cosby. Kent also noted that Spivey had alcohol in his system and was pointing a firearm at others.

Jennifer Spivey, the victim's sister, attended the bond hearing on Thursday. She stated that she had carefully reviewed the evidence until she found the note and heard the recordings. She asked the judge to ensure that justice is finally served for her brother, who had tried desperately to escape the violence that took his life.