The Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries has officially reversed its position on the prevailing wage requirements for a stalled affordable housing development in Astoria. This decision follows a recent ruling by the Oregon Court of Appeals that clarified how the law applies to residential conversions. The change allows a long-delayed project to move forward, adding dozens of much-needed apartments to the local housing stock. It also sets a precedent that may simplify similar conversions of vacant buildings across the state.

In 2025, the agency informed developers that a proposed conversion of a vacant hotel into a 64-unit affordable complex would require paying union-scale prevailing wages. That initial determination increased the project's cost by approximately $2.5 million and effectively halted construction for more than two years. Now, the bureau has withdrawn that requirement, citing a September court decision that found the agency had previously misinterpreted the legislative intent regarding housing exemptions.

The development, known as Copeland Commons, originated in 2019 when Bill Van Nostran, a retired minister, sought to address Clatsop County's high rate of homelessness. He formed a nonprofit to purchase the State Hotel, a four-story downtown structure that had remained largely vacant for over five decades. Although Oregon law generally exempts affordable housing projects from prevailing wage mandates, BOLI ruled in January 2025 that the conversion did not meet the definition of residential construction and thus required higher labor costs.

Developers argue that the agency's approach under Labor Commissioner Christina Stephenson has become increasingly strict. In a 2024 memo to Governor Tina Kotek, attorney Dina Alexander warned that BOLI was predisposed to interpreting statutes in ways that subjected projects to prevailing wage laws. She noted that the agency often sought reasons to require these wages with little regard for broader policy questions or legal rationale. This stance has been a point of contention between housing advocates and the state agency, which holds significant authority over subsidized construction funding.

Van Nostran's team appealed the bureau's decision late last year, but the agency initially rejected the appeal. However, on November 3, BOLI issued a 180-degree turn and informed the development group that it had changed its finding. This shift was directly triggered by the Court of Appeals' decision in a similar dispute involving a Salem housing project. The court stated that the legislature intended the exemption to cover affordable housing, even if some materials from a previous building were reused.

Based on this new legal precedent, Commissioner Stephenson wrote to Van Nostran's group confirming that prevailing wage laws do not apply to privately owned residential construction that predominantly provides affordable housing. Van Nostran expressed that he felt vindicated by the reversal. He estimated that the permission to avoid paying prevailing wages would save the project roughly $2.5 million in construction costs. He also credited the Oregon Journalism Project for bringing attention to the issue, noting that the coverage created a stir both locally and in Portland.

BOLI spokeswoman Rachel Mann explained that the agency's actions reflected a commitment to ensuring that pending determinations are informed by the most recent legal authority. She stated that the bureau simply responded to the court's decision. Meanwhile, State Senator Dick Anderson, a Republican and vice chair of the Senate Housing Committee, expressed mixed feelings. While pleased that Astoria will receive new housing, he remained frustrated that the agency had initially stood in the way of a project the legislature had explicitly exempted.

Anderson has introduced Senate Bill 1566 to clarify prevailing wage laws and accelerate the construction of cheaper, more abundant affordable housing. He plans to bring the bill back during the 2027 legislative session, arguing that housing providers should not have to sue to get the law applied as written. Despite this recent victory, significant disagreements remain regarding how prevailing wage laws affect other types of projects. Specifically, questions persist about whether new housing financed by the Local Innovation and Fast Track program requires prevailing wages, and whether public infrastructure construction triggers these requirements for adjacent private developments.

The bureau's current position has already stalled a major development in Eugene, highlighting the ongoing tension between state labor regulations and housing developers. Anderson believes it is time for the legislature to provide clear instructions that match the urgency of the state's homelessness crisis. He warned that Democratic leaders controlling the legislature will have to decide whether they support working families seeking homes or continue to stand in the way of essential housing solutions.