Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker has experienced a rapid ascent during the 2026 season, climbing to the second position on ESPN's Mel Kiper Jr. Big Board. This current ranking may actually undervalue his eventual standing in the 2027 NFL draft, according to recent analysis.
During a recent episode of The Adam Schefter Podcast, the ESPN NFL insider discussed the current draft order for the 2027 class. He noted that two teams holding the top two selections in April currently have confidence in their existing starting quarterbacks. This situation could lead to a competitive scenario for the top pick.
Schefter predicted that an auction would likely occur for the No. 1 selection, driven by the desire to secure Mestemaker. He suggested that teams such as the Miami Dolphins, New York Jets, Arizona Cardinals, or Cleveland Browns might seek to trade up with the Tennessee Titans or the Los Angeles Chargers to acquire the choice.
As of Week 11, both the Titans and the Chargers hold a record of 1-8, positioning them to hold the first two picks in the upcoming draft. Since Tennessee is expected to continue with former top-six pick Cam Ward, and Los Angeles is likely to stick with Justin Herbert, other teams may be eager to move up in the order.
Schefter expressed his belief that the Titans would likely retain Cam Ward even if they hold the first overall pick. He pointed out that the organization has shown conviction in their quarterback, who has navigated changes with three head coaches and three coordinors in less than two years. With eight games remaining in the season, the team appears committed to providing Ward with consistency.
The ideal scenario for Tennessee, according to Schefter, would involve another team landing the No. 2 pick and providing the Titans with an additional asset to move up one slot. In that case, Tennessee could select Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, who is currently ranked No. 1 overall by Kiper. Smith would join his former college teammate, Carnell Tate, who is also a wide receiver for the Cowboys.
Last week, Mestemaker addressed questions about his potential entry into the 2027 draft by stating that there is nothing he can do about the situation right now. He chose to defer further comments on his immediate plans for the future.
Before the season began, Kiper had identified Mestemaker as a potential first-round candidate but placed him in a category of maybe candidates. Since transferring from North Texas to follow coach Eric Morris to Oklahoma State, Mestemaker has performed impressively. In his first 10 games with the Cowboys, he has accumulated 3,239 passing yards, 30 passing touchdowns, and four rushing touchdowns.
Schefter also highlighted the general increase in value for quarterbacks during draft season. He noted that Notre Dame's CJ Carr, who still has college eligibility, could rise in rankings due to his physical talent and the potential ceiling of his team. Schefter summarized the current market sentiment by stating that quarterbacks are essentially currency, and teams will take the one they love if the opportunity arises.
ESPN's Pete Thamel conducted a midseason poll of 25 NFL scouts and executives last month to determine who would be the top quarterback in next year's draft. The results showed strong support for Mestemaker, with 17 of the 25 respondents selecting him. Carr finished in second place with four votes in the same survey.







