American special envoy Jared Kushner has discussed granting Ukraine full membership in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization if the country hands over territory currently held in the eastern Donbas region to Russia. This proposal has been raised in closed-door peace negotiations over the past several months, according to a report published by The Wall Street Journal on Thursday.

The report indicates that Kushner and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff have presented this idea to various European officials. The most recent instance of this discussion took place last week at a military airfield in Dublin. There, the US representatives met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, his adviser Rustem Umerov, and several European national security advisers. The topic was also addressed during talks involving Ukrainian, European, and Russian officials in the United Arab Emirates during the same week. One European leader noted that the concept had been introduced during a phone call as early as August.

US negotiators have outlined two distinct scenarios for ending the conflict. The first involves Ukraine relinquishing the remaining parts of the Donbas region it still controls in return for full NATO membership. The second scenario proposes freezing the war along the current front line, which would leave a portion of the Donbas in Ukrainian hands. Under this alternative, Ukraine would receive security guarantees through an international treaty involving the United States and potentially European allies. A US official clarified that both Ukraine and Russia must agree to any final deal, and that many ideas are currently under discussion.

It remains unclear how seriously the United States is considering the NATO membership option, particularly since President Donald Trump previously ruled out Ukrainian membership early last year. NATO expansion requires consensus among all members, and some allies have historically opposed admitting Kyiv. According to attendees at talks in Berlin on Thursday, German hosts were hesitant to pursue the issue. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has reportedly told aides that Ukraine would not join the alliance during his lifetime. In contrast, French President Emmanuel Macron stated after the Berlin meeting that the time had come to discuss Ukraine's potential membership.

President Zelensky confirmed last week that the idea had been raised during negotiations. He told reporters that the Americans asked what would happen if Ukraine joined NATO and whether the country would then withdraw from the contested territory. Despite these discussions, Zelensky has repeatedly emphasized that Ukraine does not intend to give up its land.

Speaking alongside European leaders in Berlin on Thursday, Kushner indicated that Moscow has become more comfortable with the concept of NATO-style protections for Ukraine. He stated that any security guarantee for Ukraine would likely be based on Article 5 of the NATO treaty, which defines an attack on one member as an attack on all. Kushner described providing an Article 5-like guarantee as a significant step for America, noting that President Trump is open to the idea if it serves American interests.

However, the Russian government pushed back against the proposal the following day. Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said that any form of quasi-membership in NATO for Ukraine would be unacceptable. He urged that the irrevocable nature of Russia's demand, which states that Ukraine must not join the alliance, be formally recognized.

The divergent reactions from European leaders and the Russian government highlight the complexity of the ongoing diplomatic efforts. While the US continues to explore various frameworks for a peace deal, the prospect of linking territorial concessions to alliance membership remains a contentious issue among the parties involved.