The Commercial Court of Odesa Oblast has issued a ruling requiring the Russian Federation to pay UAH 11.54 million, which is approximately US$256,400, to the Nova Kakhovka Electromechanical Plant Trade and Production Association. The compensation is intended to cover lost profits for the year 2022. The plant initiated the legal action against the state, represented by its Ministry of Foreign Affairs, as well as against several prominent Russian individuals.

The company’s production facilities are located in Nova Kakhovka, a city in Kherson Oblast that has been under temporary Russian occupation since the beginning of the full-scale war. An assessment conducted by court-appointed expert Mykola Korinko determined that the plant was unable to generate its expected profits during the specified period due to the occupation of its site.

In addition to the lost profits, the plant sought to recover UAH 16.87 million, or about US$374,800, for the value of its fixed assets. However, the court rejected this portion of the claim. The decision was based on the finding that the expert had not adequately assessed the losses arising from the loss of non-current assets, meaning the claim was not fully supported by the required technical evaluation.

The legal case involved a broader list of defendants beyond the Russian state. The plant sought to hold Vladimir Putin, the leader of the Kremlin, jointly and severally liable for the payment. Other named individuals included Russian film director and propagandist Nikita Mikhalkov, Alfa Group co-founders Mikhail Fridman and Petr Aven, and Russian State Duma deputy Arkady Ponomarev.

The claimant also requested that the court order the seizure of any property belonging to Russia and the named individuals located in Spain. The court dismissed the proceedings regarding these specific claims, stating that they did not fall within the jurisdiction of commercial courts. Furthermore, the court refused to order the seizure of property directly, noting that such actions are the responsibility of state or private enforcement officers rather than the commercial judiciary.

Ultimately, the court limited its ruling to the recovery of lost profits from the Russian Federation. The Nova Kakhovka Electromechanical Plant, which specializes in the manufacture of three-phase asynchronous electric motors, is directed by Yevhenii Oborin, who is also its beneficial owner. The ruling marks a significant step in the legal efforts by Ukrainian businesses to seek financial redress for damages caused by the ongoing conflict.

This decision follows a similar precedent set by the Commercial Court of Luhansk Oblast. In that case, the court ordered Russia to pay UAH 65.36 million, approximately US$1.6 million, in compensation for property damage to Oliiar, a private business. Oliiar suffered losses when its warehouse in the occupied city of Svatove was seized, resulting in the loss of its sunflower seed stock.