New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin condemned public expressions of support for terrorist groups during a Monday conference on antisemitism, saying such displays were becoming normalized in the city. Speaking at Touro University, she urged greater attention to education and called on attendees to challenge antisemitism publicly, including on social media.
Menin criticized efforts to justify the October 7, 2023, attack on Israel or blame Jews for it. She recalled seeing demonstrators outside her City Hall window on this year's anniversary carrying Hamas and Hezbollah flags and displaying pictures of Yahya Sinwar in admiration. Sinwar, the late Hamas leader, was the architect of the 2023 invasion. Menin described the normalization of such scenes as “shocking and abhorrent.”
Anti-Zionist demonstrations marking the anniversary took place at Columbia University and City Hall, and targeted a coexistence event in Union Square. The Times of Israel reported seeing Hamas and Hezbollah flags, along with photographs of Sinwar and other terrorist leaders. Some participants explicitly supported US-designated terrorist organizations, a feature the outlet described as increasingly common at the city's anti-Zionist rallies in recent years.
The first Jewish person to serve as City Council speaker, Menin is the daughter and granddaughter of Holocaust survivors. Fighting antisemitism has been a priority for her since she assumed the position at the beginning of the year. Jews face more hate crimes in New York City than all other groups combined.
Menin questioned the effectiveness of New York State's required Holocaust education, arguing that meaningful instruction was lacking. She pointed to a 2020 Claims Conference study that found 34 percent of young people in New York believed the Holocaust was mythical or exaggerated, or were uncertain whether it had happened.
She also discussed her opposition to the Metropolitan Museum of Art's proposed recognition of designer John Galliano, who has a history of antisemitism. The museum, a public institution receiving City Council funding, abandoned the plan after pressure from Menin and others. Menin said the prospect of honoring Galliano at the Met Gala had made her feel physically ill, and she welcomed the reversal.
Touro University, a private Jewish university in New York City, hosted elected officials including City Council Members Inna Vernikov and Simcha Felder and State Assembly Member Simcha Eisenstein. Jewish academics, researchers and legal advocates also addressed the symposium. Menin encouraged participants to overcome any reluctance to speak publicly against antisemitism.
Participants differed over the Jewish community's prospects and the outlook for confronting antisemitism and anti-Zionism. Speakers nevertheless agreed in characterizing anti-Zionism as discrimination against Jews and calling for changes to communal advocacy. David Harris of the research center ISGAP urged a reassessment of established Jewish organizations' approaches, more sophisticated voting decisions and greater care in donations. He portrayed the community as losing ground while suggesting there was still time to change course.







