The United States Department of Justice submitted a legal filing on Thursday, November 19, requesting that a federal appeals court dismiss a lawsuit the administration had filed prior to the midterm elections. The suit originally sought to block the official certification of the Alaska Senate race results if Democrat Mary Peltola had emerged as the victor. By moving to declare the case moot, the administration effectively conceded that the election outcome had been finalized.
The legal dispute centered on the presence of a second candidate named Daniel Sullivan on the Alaska ballot. This candidate shared the same name as the incumbent Republican senator, Dan Sullivan. The Alaska Supreme Court had previously ruled that the second Sullivan's candidacy was legally permissible and that he was entitled to remain on the ballot. The administration's original argument, directed by President Donald Trump, suggested that a Peltola victory should not be certified until an investigation could determine whether voters had been confused by the duplicate name. However, officials never clarified how such an investigation could be conducted given the secret nature of the ballot.
Mary Peltola won the election with 50.13% of the total vote. This margin gave her a higher total than the combined votes of all other candidates, including both the incumbent senator and the second Daniel Sullivan. The second Sullivan was reportedly recruited to enter the race by Democratic figures to siphon votes away from the sitting Republican senator. Peltola denied any personal involvement in encouraging the second candidate's run, despite earlier reports from The New York Times alleging that her staffers were part of the scheme.
The move to dismiss the lawsuit came two days after the race was officially decided. It followed the conclusion of Alaska's vote count process, which utilized ranked-choice tabulation to determine winners in races where no single candidate received more than 50% of the votes cast. This method of counting applied to several contests, including the election for the state's sole representative in the US House of Representatives.
The controversy extended beyond the Senate race to the House contest. One candidate, Eric Hafner, was also included on the ballot in what appeared to be an attempt to confuse voters. Hafner was allowed to run as a Democrat over the objections of the state party, despite having no connection to Alaska and currently serving a sentence in a federal prison in New York. He received 22,715 votes in the election.
Analysts noted that had all of Hafner's ballots been cast for the state party-backed candidate, Hill, the outcome of the House race might have been different. Specifically, Hill would have defeated Begich under that scenario. The inclusion of candidates with no local ties or legal status has raised questions about ballot design and voter clarity in the state's unique electoral process.
Mary Peltola, who is Yup'ik, is set to join Senator-elect Peggy Flanagan from Minnesota in the US Senate. Flanagan, a member of the White Earth band of Ojibwe, will serve alongside Peltola as the first two Native American women to hold seats in the upper chamber of the US Congress. Their election marks a historic shift in the demographic composition of the Senate.
The dismissal request signals a potential end to the legal challenges surrounding the Alaska election results. By arguing that the case is moot, the Trump administration acknowledges that the threshold for victory was met and that the certification process can proceed without further federal judicial intervention. This development clears the path for Peltola to officially take her seat in the new Congress.
The legal strategy highlights the administration's earlier concerns about voter confusion and the integrity of the ballot. While the courts had already validated the second Sullivan's place on the ballot, the DOJ's intervention added a layer of federal scrutiny to the state's internal election procedures. The resolution of this lawsuit may set a precedent for how future challenges to ballot design and candidate eligibility are handled in close races.
As the Alaska election results are finalized, attention turns to the broader implications for the 119th Congress. The addition of two Native American women to the Senate brings new perspectives to legislative debates. Meanwhile, the House race in Alaska continues to be analyzed in light of the ranked-choice voting results and the unexpected performance of candidate Eric Hafner.







