A federal aircraft built to identify dangerous chemicals during disasters has responded to only seven emergencies since early 2021, raising concerns among former staff about the Environmental Protection Agency’s ability to assess toxic releases. The program, known as Aspect, previously flew missions over disasters including Hurricane Katrina and the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
The single-engine Cessna remained grounded during an ammonia leak in Weatherford, Oklahoma, that injured 74 people in November 2025, a refinery fire in Port Arthur, Texas, in March and fatal explosions at a Toledo, Ohio, recycling plant in August. Mark Thomas, who managed Aspect for 18 years, told the nonprofit newsroom Floodlight that the plane would have attended all three incidents a decade earlier.
An EPA inspector general review in June found that Aspect had lost its ability to identify chemicals within minutes. Manual analysis instead took about a week, undermining its usefulness for urgent evacuation decisions. The EPA attributed the problem to aging chemical sensors and expects replacements to operate by mid-2027. Thomas, longtime scientist Robert Kroutil and former program manager Rick Turville disputed that explanation, saying the existing sensors still work and that expertise and initiative have been lost.
Aspect moved from the Department of Defense to the EPA after the September 11, 2001, attacks and has completed more than 80 emergency missions over 25 years. During a 2019 reorganization, staff were instructed to move to Texas or face termination, according to an internal memo. Thomas retired, other key employees departed and one accepted a demotion to remain in Kansas. Former staff said experienced scientists were not adequately replaced and managers stopped actively encouraging deployments.
The response to the February 3, 2023, train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio, illustrated those concerns. Aspect was requested more than two days after the crash, missing the deliberate burning of vinyl chloride from five railcars. Kroutil said its February 7 flight collected only eight minutes of chemical data. The National Transportation Safety Board later deemed the burn unnecessary. An inspector general investigation found shortcomings in EPA documentation and communication about the aircraft’s capabilities, and an audit is examining the derailment response and air-quality assurances.
Aspect’s next emergency deployment came 19 months later, after an August 22, 2025, explosion at Smitty’s Supply in Roseland, Louisiana. The resulting fire lasted two weeks and triggered an evacuation within one mile. Nine days after the explosion, the EPA published flight findings showing ozone and three other pollutants at concentrations well below levels expected to cause health effects.
Kroutil subsequently spent four weeks manually examining the raw flight data. He reported high concentrations of toluene, trichloroethylene and naphthalene, identifying the latter two as carcinogens and toluene as a neurotoxicant. He concluded that toluene concentrations could have endangered nearby communities. Resident Ronnie Polezcek, whose farm was coated in residue, said contamination remained on much of his property more than a year later.
Procurement records show the EPA bypassed competitive bidding to award Telops a $1.7 million sensor replacement contract. Former Aspect personnel questioned whether the equipment would improve detection. Independent spectrometer expert Chris Manning said it could supplement existing sensors but would be a poor substitute because it is slower, less sensitive and less suitable for moving targets.
Telops’s parent company, Exosens, said the systems employ fundamentally different technologies and that its sensors can identify hundreds of chemicals through additional analysis. The aircraft will likely remain unavailable for chemical emergencies until integration in early to mid-2027. The EPA did not answer Floodlight’s questions about the program’s decline, emergency responses or replacement sensors.







